Why health care providers & public health professionals say vaccines are not the cause of recent acute flaccid myelitis (AFM) cases

Communicable Disease, Germs, Jeff Duchin, Kids & Families, Other, vaccines, , , , 4 Comments

By Dr. Jeff Duchin, Health Officer

Recent cases of acute flaccid myelitis (AFM) locally and across the US have parents, health care providers and public health professionals deeply concerned and looking hard for the cause, which remains unknown. Based on what we do know about causes of AFM, the leading suspect is infection with a virus because several viruses are known to cause AFM in a very small number of people who become infected.

Some have expressed the opinion that vaccines may be causing the AFM cases. Like most children in the US, children who develop AFM have usually received recommended childhood vaccines at the appropriate ages. However, there are a number of reasons why health care providers and public health professionals say childhood vaccines are not likely to be the cause of the current increase in AFM cases:

  • AFM cases are seen at a variety of ages and not at an age when a particular childhood vaccine is regularly given. The average age of AFM cases in the largest published reports from the US is 7 and 9 years, and the age of reported AFM cases ranges from 6 months to 21 years and older. So, the ages of AFM cases vary and are past the time when most childhood vaccines are routinely given.
  • Current childhood vaccines are not associated with AFM, and the same vaccines have been used for many years prior to the increase in AFM cases. There have been no changes in the vaccines in recent years, including when the increase in AFM was noted in 2014.
  • Previously, AFM was a rare complication of the oral polio vaccine used in the US before 2000. That vaccine used a live, weakened polio virus. After 2000, only the inactivated polio vaccine (no live virus) has been in used in the US, and it does not cause AFM. Also, since that time, AFM has not been reported through ongoing vaccine safety monitoring in the US.
  • The 2014 increase in AFM cases was temporally associated with an outbreak of a virus (EV-D68) that is related to other similar viruses known to cause AFM. However, whether EV-D68 has a role in AFM cases remains unproven and the investigation to determine the cause of recent AFM cases is ongoing.
  • There have been many studies of vaccine safety. None of the vaccines currently used in the United States are known to cause AFM. However, in the rare instance that AFM does occur, it is usually after infection with certain viruses. Most children (over 70%) with AFM have reported symptoms of a viral respiratory or GI infection preceding the onset of AFM.
  • And finally, childhood vaccinations are given every month of the year based on when children are born and their ages, but AFM has occurred seasonally, peaking in late summer or fall, when certain viruses associated with AFM are also circulating.

In summary, available evidence does not support the claim that vaccines are related to AFM. Ongoing, intensive investigation into the cause and mechanism of AFM will remain a priority for public health and medical professionals. As more information becomes available, you can find updates here.

4 thoughts on “Why health care providers & public health professionals say vaccines are not the cause of recent acute flaccid myelitis (AFM) cases”

  1. And again – no answers in this article – I had asked the question if there was a commonality that all the children currently affected with AFM here in Washington State had just recently had the flu vaccination. No one is talking about that!

    1. Hi Donna,

      Our investigation so far suggests that the flu vaccine is not a common exposure among the cases. I hope that answers your question. Thanks!

      1. I’ll be a little more blunt.

        How many of these Washington state victims HAD recently received the flu vaccine? Or ANY vaccine? Within a month or two of exhibiting AFM symptoms?

        “Flu shot is not a common exposure” doesn’t really answer the question, since people are not cookie cutouts and we don’t react the same to any particular stimuli.

        This is obviously an autoimmune reaction to SOMETHING. Previously harmless viruses suddenly causing the immune system to go haywire. What’s causing the bodies of these kids to react this way?

  2. I have had the exact same question for the last month regarding a possible connection between AFM and the flu shot. I have asked my own provider as well as those of my three children. Everyone states that they don’t believe it is connected, but can give no concrete evidence to prove this assumption. I would like to hear the facts as well on the children in WA who have been proven to have AFM and whether they had a flu shot in the weeks leading up to their illness. My children have not received the flu shot yet this year specifically because I have not found any evidence or reassurance proving that it could not be connected to AFM. It seems strange that since we already know that a similar illness causing paralysis (Guillain-Barre Syndrome) is a possible, albeit rare, side effect of the flu shot, that public health officials have absolutely ruled out the possibility that the shot is not connected to AFM. Thank you in advance for answering this question more directly.

Comments are closed.